Today I find myself puzzling over the weird fact of my existence. The Internet created an opportunity to show a side of myself that I had long kept hidden. I am transgendered; in spite of being born and raised male the core of my identity is female. It is not a convenient or desirable situation, and it puts me in constant conflict between who I am and what I am. It would be simpler to let myself be defined by my body but the simple fact is that I am defined by my mind, or to be more accurate, my mind is what defines me. It is the nature of my thoughts and feelings that define me as a person, and it is by examining and understanding my thoughts and feelings that I find myself forced to admit I am a girl in spite of being a boy. It could mean that my brain structure and chemistry is feminine, or it could mean that the character of a soul is stronger than the imprint of a body. There is no way to know. What I do know is that being male, thinking, acting and being perceived as a man, does not make me one; it does not change who I am. It only means that few people are ever likely to see me for who I am.
That is the real curse, the real tragedy of being transgendered. Short of changing the way people perceive me, by changing my physical appearance, there is little chance I will ever be accepted for who I am. Actually, short of a miraculous and literal metamorphosis, there is no chance. What I am stands in the way. What I am distorts me no matter how I appear. I am not a woman. Looking like a woman, dressing like a woman, taking hormones and getting surgery to make my anatomy more like a woman’s, will not make me a woman. A change from transgendered to transsexual is a lateral move. I’ve been tempted, because it would allow me to be much closer to my natural self, but I’ve always known that the physical facts would still prevent people from seeing me for who I am.
But, who am I? That is the question it always comes back to. That is the question that stops me in my tracks every time I meet someone, or interview for a job. I am a lifetime full of facts that obscure the truth. I am a consciousness trapped in a reality that denies me my own reality. My body is nothing more than the earth in which my awareness is rooted. To conform to the flesh, I have to deny my own identity and assume the one that circumstance has provided. To survive, I have to conform to the flesh, and the pain it causes leaves me with no doubt as to the existence of the soul. The only thing in reality that can explain the cause and nature of this pain is the fact of my own reality, the fact that I, myself, am real. This pain, though it has repeatedly broken me and driven me to the brink of suicide, is one thing that assures me I am true.
I know who I am. In spite of having nothing to support me, nothing to confirm my identity, nothing in this world to base it upon but the understanding of what makes me true to myself, I know the truth. I have always known it, even when I tried to deny it for the sake of others who expected or demanded that I conform to their perceptions of me. I am different from most people only in knowing exactly the cost of the circumstances of my birth. In philosophy and religion, it is common to hear that we choose our place in reality, but if you examine it more carefully the choice is not one based on getting what we want out of life, it is based on getting what we need to perfect ourselves; it is a test, a trial by fire. I assumed that my test was about self-sacrifice and accepting reality. Acting on this belief, I nearly destroyed myself.
It is obvious when you think about it. It does not matter what you are if you lose sight of who you are. If you take the person out of the picture, it ceases to have a frame of reference, a perspective that gives it significance and meaning. All of my life I have listened to people asking “what is the point of all this?” and as soon as I realized that without us all of this has no point, I understood. We are the point of all of this. We give this focus. The problem has always been that we have never really understood our purpose. We do not understand what it means to be the point of existence. In today’s world, “existential” is practically a dirty word. No one wants to be existential. We have turned our backs on the spiritual, the ephemeral, the insubstantial, intangible and invisible, and in the process turned our backs on ourselves. This is the path to destruction.
All of the pain and suffering in the world is a product of us walking down this path. If we fail to see the point in our own existence, we cannot truly see the point in anyone’s existence. In a pointless existence, we are driven only by the impulses to avoid pain and seek pleasure and either way we are rendered too numb to think. Without thought we are blind and indifferent to the consequences of our actions, the pain and suffering we cause. Instead of thinking, we rationalize. Instead of solving problems that we have created, we justify them and in the process we create injustice. We end up pitting ourselves against each other, struggling for power to rise above the conflict, creating institutions that marginalize and alienate us further. Each step on this path of destruction strips away a layer of our souls and makes it easier for us to destroy each other.
As a misfit, I have always been painfully sensitive to the suffering of others, and the world’s suffering eclipses the imagination. The mere apprehension of it is overwhelming. Everyone is aware of it on some level and I am sure it is the weight of that apprehension that discourages so many, leaving them wondering if there is any point to existence, unable to understand how a meaningful universe could be so cruel and indifferent. I usually wonder why I am so desperate to find a place for myself in it. All I know is, this world is the one dream we all share and I am tired of dreaming alone.
May 11, 2008 at 4:38 pm
Well put. Welcome to my world. The world where you are “tired of dreaming alone.” Well, I used to feel that way. However, ever since taking those initial steps of acknowledging my true self and identity, I surprisingly found a group of like-minded individuals who care for me as I’ve come to care for them. And I’m beginning to realize I’m not as “whacked” as I thought I was. Being transgendered does not mean that I am unintelligent, unapathetic, or deviant. In fact, I have gained an immeasurable outpouring of love in these unexpected friendships.
I hope you may find yourself able to hold on to the glimpse of hope that I have by surrendering and allowing myself to simply be who I am. The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not overcome it.
Blessings,
Lori
http://loriannetucson.wordpress.com
May 11, 2008 at 6:57 pm
You said,
“A change from transgendered to transsexual is a lateral move. I’ve been tempted, because it would allow me to be much closer to my natural self, but I’ve always known that the physical facts would still prevent people from seeing me for who I am.”
Actually, that hasn’t been my experience at all, far from it, in fact. I started living full time as Abby one year ago yesterday and the reduction of the paradox in my own existence and the resulting peace and joy that I experience every day has been nothing short of miraculous. Although hormones have changed some of “the physical facts” of my own existence, the one that most people seem to focus on in deciding whether someone is “really” a man or a woman has not. Nonetheless, everywhere I go I am accepted as the woman I have always known myself to be and that I now present to the world. No one cares and no one asks about that one remaining “physical fact.” It has in no way prevented “people from seeing me for who I am.” After all, we are not our bodies.
May 11, 2008 at 9:27 pm
This is a brilliantly written essay on the transgender experience! I’m not nearly as eloquent in my ability to write, but I can certainly relate to the subject, being transgendered myself. It’s certainly not something we would choose to be, but we are forced to deal with it in some way, be it good or bad. I hope you are able to deal with it with some success.
Amber
May 12, 2008 at 1:44 pm
Lori, I am happy for you that you have found others to support you and share with. As you say, being transgendered does nothing to diminish our worth and ability as people; it does not make us inhuman or, as you say, deviant — though it can drive us crazy! But it does mean we are not the men or women people take us to be on sight. The experiences we have in life make us different from people blessed with congruent sex and gender. Those experiences give us amazing insight into humanity, an understanding that bridges the gap between men and women. I am long past the days when I thought I was alone in this experience. It has also been some time since the people I started transition with moved on to new lives and left me behind. I do not blame them; I am the one who broke and fell through the cracks! I do have hope of having such friends and such support again. I do not think I could make any progress without it.
Abby, if I could transition — if I had the stability, the finances and the moral support required — I would. Even at 6′2″ with large hands and blunt elbows, I’ve been blessed with an androgynous face and might be able to pass for a very tall woman. If that is the assumption that people jumped to, it would not displease me at all. What I spoke of, when I said that the physical facts would still prevent people from seeing me for who I am, was the fact that I cannot alter my history. Trying to hide from it would be just as agonizing as having to hide my true identity. I was also making a deeply veiled reference to the fact that transsexuals have been raped and murdered because of how they were perceived. Knowing that who I am is more important important that what I am does not mean that what I am is not more important to someone else. That is the conundrum.
Amber, I have been able to survive, and the irony is that few people can understand what an incredible victory that is — each and every day. Once again, I thank you for your compliments on my writing; along with my artistic ability, it is a product of so many desperate years of struggling to find a way to express myself. I will add your hope to mine that life will allow me some more conventional successes! I still find it an insane irony that my best hope of becoming woman is to find enough success in the world as a man to afford it!
May 13, 2008 at 5:27 am
Perfectly written response, my friend. In fact, I would hope you consider cross posting or contributing your own ideas to a site known as http://transcendgender.com . Abby and Amber also contribute, and many of us are able to discuss these very topics in a larger forum. If you’re interested, or just want to rant or talk, you can email me at loriannetucson (at) yahoo (dot) com.
If not, I’ve still added you to my personal blogroll. I look forward to continue reading your future posts.
Lori
May 13, 2008 at 5:51 pm
[...] in Uncategorized at 5:51 pm by eyeofparadox The response I received to my last post, Conundrum, prompted me to check out the recent posts of the people who commented or posted blogs in the [...]
May 13, 2008 at 9:06 pm
Lori, if cross-posting means what I think it does, I would indeed consider that or contributing to transcendgender — although, for the latter I cannot promise to be prolific. My own blogs have been rather sporadic, squeezed into spare moments that coincide with inspiration or fits of pique!